• Hi all and welcome to TheWoodHaven2 brought into the 21st Century, kicking and screaming! We all have Alasdair to thank for the vast bulk of the heavy lifting to get us here, no more so than me because he's taken away a huge burden of responsibility from my shoulders and brought us to this new shiny home, with all your previous content (hopefully) still intact! Please peruse and feed back. There is still plenty to do, like changing the colour scheme, adding the banner graphic, tweaking the odd setting here and there so I have added a new thread in the 'Technical Issues, Bugs and Feature Requests' forum for you to add any issues you find, any missing settings or just anything you'd like to see added/removed from the feature set that Xenforo offers. We will get to everything over the coming weeks so please be patient, but add anything at all to the thread I mention above and we promise to get to them over the next few days/weeks/months. In the meantime, please enjoy!

Bog oak tenon saw project

Mike G

Petrified Pine
Joined
Jul 30, 2014
Messages
12,503
Reaction score
3,086
Location
Suffolk
Name
Mike
For 30 years or more this awful freebie has kicked around in the back of drawers in my workshop, unusable on wood. I can't remember whether it came free in a Cornflakes packet, or with maybe a handsaw, but it was so awful that the last time I used it was as a scraper on some rock-hard plaster to try to form a key (it was useless even at that). Here it is in all its glory:

1j3Uk4U.png

iFYp9DI.png

Isn't it gorgeous?

It had some sort of coating on it which had prevented it rusting, so cleaning it up wasn't very difficult (120 grit and a squirt of WD40):

hfYNu6G.png

Being hardpoint (heat treated) the teeth were too hard to file off, so I marked a line and ground them off on the bench grinder:

S1HEUTH.png

There wasn't an awful lot of merit in the handle, so I ummed and ahhed for a while before deciding to make a new one. I just happened to have a scrap or two of bog oak kicking around, so I thought I might try that. I traced over a handle from my tenon saw which I've always found really comfortable:

X4d6fik.png

I've never owned a pistol grip saw, so I thought I'd give that a try. I sketched out the bits I didn't need, and in a few minutes on the pillar drill and the bandsaw produced a blank:

6yGhADH.png

It's not too late to go back to the original handle, but the saw nuts will only screw into the plastic so many times........ Anyway, a few minutes with a rounding over bit on the router (mind that end grain!), then rasps, sandpaper, bits of dowel, chisels........you know, getting rid of all the stuff I didn't want, I ended up with a really comfortable handle:

w1AqGTl.png

Cleaned up with some white spirit:

SXSlUtc.png

1pHHHlC.png

LsjTul7.png

jWZvkB0.png

It'll probably need some teeth, I guess. I've never cut teeth from scratch before, so after filing the edge dead straight, I printed off some lines at 12 per inch (my other saws are 15 and 21 TPI, so I've got the finer stuff covered):

9hNVEnD.png

Then taped a section of it over the edge of the plate:

wexswhh.png

I transferred those lines to the plate by sawing directly through the paper with a junior hacksaw. I sawed too deep, as you'll see later:

U9CAavQ.png

pXx9X6L.png

Interestingly, I picked the plate up at this stage and without a handle, used it to cut pretty cleanly through a piece of 2x1 pine!!

Now, I've heard one or two people talk about using a soft start to their tenon saws, going from a relaxed profile to a rip profile over the first couple of inches, so I thought I'd give that a try:

clwHDRW.png

You can see the slope of the front of each tooth change from 60 degrees to vertical over the first 2 inches. You can also see that the over-deep hacksaw cuts have left their mark. This saw won't really be right on this sharpening, but I'll get it spot on next time.

My damn setting pliers snapped in half whilst setting the teeth. Cheap rubbish only lasted 40 years:

xiBcXJe.png

It works, even without any saw nuts:

WZrKJ7x.png

I really like the gradation in colour in the handle, which just has a coat or 2 of Osmo on it, and some wax:

69UrF9N.png

And just a reminder of what it looked like when it started:

iFYp9DI.png

I'll order the saw nuts on Monday, and they'll be the most expensive part of the saw.
 
Roger,

I have acquired at least two, I suspect that it is at least three, saw sets over the years and after a search of all the likely hiding places eventually found two no name sets huddled together, they would appear to work but are not as nice looking as yours. If you are prepared to slum it I will send you one, the handle or bits may even be interchangeable. They are painted in a dull camouflage green increasing the chances they will never be found again.


Nice restoration on the saw, I am half way through a Diston restoration but at current rate of progress it will be another year. I am on my third day of fitting a door! Constant interruptions and priority tasks make progress difficult, at least I have finished the floor.

Kevin
 
Thank you for your kind offer, Kevin, but I'll pass as I've got too many other projects on the go and/or half-finished. SWMBO would kill me if I embarked on a saw restoration project !!
 
HappyHacker":39f3jtc1 said:
......I have acquired at least two, I suspect that it is at least three, saw sets over the years and after a search of all the likely hiding places eventually found two no name sets huddled together, they would appear to work but are not as nice looking as yours. If you are prepared to slum it I will send you one.........

That's fantastic, Kevin, thanks.

I'll drop you a PM. Cheers.
 
Confused.com is me. One day I may work out what is going on. I might even find where the others are hiding, I know I have more than 2.

I have got your PM and will go and sort out packing it, hopefully in post tomorrow.

No need for beer tokens, do someone else a favour in the future :)
 
I did find this while searching. A niece bit of casting. Says German on the other side. No idea how to work it as not had any need to set a saw in recent years.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20190414_182429333.jpg
    IMG_20190414_182429333.jpg
    148.3 KB · Views: 6,936
Yes nice job
Lee Valley used to have free downloads of various handle shapes.
This is one of them:

a7ea30c3c1bd62c173e02aa2a27338cc.jpg


eacfcc6c31b829ccfe79dd9e76ef20d2.jpg


Rod
 
The saw nuts arrived today. Yeah, it would been better if they were steel:

8HBTX86.png

It works, albeit a little harsh (feels like one tooth is prominent somewhere):

h7MYHP1.png

Anyone who fancies making their own tool handles, or anything else, out of bog oak, sale day is soon!
 
Back
Top