TBH I think that the wood being marked can be just as much a factor as the type of gauge.
I mostly use Veritas gauges but I do know that when going along pine - as per yesterday - the grain is the bigger thing and it means that whatever gauge I use, marking lightly at first and then more heavily is key. That is less so with hardwoods like e.g. cherry or maple.
I find it somehow more satisfying to use a pin gauge but that requires getting the hang of it, so when in doubt I opt for the Veritas wheel gauge.
I mostly use Veritas gauges but I do know that when going along pine - as per yesterday - the grain is the bigger thing and it means that whatever gauge I use, marking lightly at first and then more heavily is key. That is less so with hardwoods like e.g. cherry or maple.
I find it somehow more satisfying to use a pin gauge but that requires getting the hang of it, so when in doubt I opt for the Veritas wheel gauge.