Black Walnut turning saw made from kit.

[SteveMP]

Wasn’t sure if this should go in projects or hand tools. This was the Gramercy Tools kit, got the hardware kit with the turned handles since I don’t really have a lathe. I used the plans available on their site to make all the wood bits. The tension pin was tricky without a lathe, but turned out ok, was just a TON of sanding. The other challenge was the loose mortise and tenons with curved faces. This joint has to move but not just completely fall apart when you loosen the tensioner. All the corners are faceted. And what i originally thought were merely decorative grooves near the brass pins, is actually a really handy finger groove that helps guide the saw with your index finger. Finished with my current favorite finish BeeNooba.

 

[Dr.Al]

Lovely. I'd like to make a frame saw at some point (it might have to wait until I've got some space to store it in though!}

 

[SteveMP]

Lovely. I'd like to make a frame saw at some point (it might have to wait until I've got some space to store it in though!}

Thank you. I'll try and post my roubo frame saw at some point. I have to dig out from behind a large heavy cabinet in the garage. Its HUGE and i don't use it a ton so it stores away mostly. The way garages are built here there is a concrete footing around hte whole permiter that the walls are on top of, so there is a gap behind stuff thats on the floor, and its shoved back there with all kind of other "thin" stuff

I also have an old vintage German frame saw that works pretty well. Its much smaller than the roubo. Kind of inbetween this and hte roubo.

 

[Dr.Al]

Thank you. I'll try and post my frame saw at some point. I have to dig out from behind a large heavy cabinet in the garage. Its HUGE and i don't use it a ton so it stores away mostly

I was definitely imagining something fairly small (perhaps that makes it a turning saw?} but I'm not really sure to be honest. I just thought it would be an interesting project really.

 

[SteveMP]

I was definitely imagining something fairly small (perhaps that makes it a turning saw?} but I'm not really sure to be honest. I just thought it would be an interesting project really.

Terminology doesn't seem to be super consistent. And perhaps regional. But from what i tend to hear is a smaller saw is typically called "bow saw" or "turning saw" as far as I know. Once you get to "frame saw" it tends to be in the 400mm, 600mm, 700mm range of blade. My roubo frame saw the blade alone is 4' long. But I guess technically they all have a frame, lol.

FYI, in Europe, this is basically the kit I used:

Bow Saw Kit consisting of 3 Blades and 2 Pins GRAMERCY TOOLS – Buy Frame Saws online - FineTools

Buy Bow Saw Kit consisting of 3 Blades and 2 Pins GRAMERCY TOOLS online in category Frame Saws | Wide selectionl ✓ fast shipping ✓ great service ✓ shop now!

www.fine-tools.com

 

[Mike G]

That's a nice looking saw. I use mine quite a bit.

My understanding of the terminology is that a frame saw has a blade in the middle and is used for ripping, sometimes with two people. I tend to call mine a bow saw......but I know zippo about these things, and will rely on one of the Andys for the real answer. This what I think of as a frame saw:

 

[SteveMP]

I was definitely imagining something fairly small (perhaps that makes it a turning saw?} but I'm not really sure to be honest. I just thought it would be an interesting project really.

Pic for scale
The turning saw i made with an old vintage German frame saw.

 

[PAC1]

Very nice. I made one in American Cherry a few years ago.

 

[Dr.Al]

Terminology doesn't seem to be super consistent. And perhaps regional. But from what i tend to hear is a smaller saw is typically called "bow saw" or "turning saw" as far as I know. Once you get to "frame saw" it tends to be in the 400mm, 600mm, 700mm range of blade. My roubo frame saw the blade alone is 4' long. But I guess technically they all have a frame, lol.

FYI, in Europe, this is basically the kit I used:

Bow Saw Kit consisting of 3 Blades and 2 Pins GRAMERCY TOOLS – Buy Frame Saws online - FineTools

Buy Bow Saw Kit consisting of 3 Blades and 2 Pins GRAMERCY TOOLS online in category Frame Saws | Wide selectionl ✓ fast shipping ✓ great service ✓ shop now!

www.fine-tools.com

That's useful, thanks. I might have to add that to the birthday wish list!

I tend to call mine a bow saw

I don't think I ever would have thought to look that name up: I always think of these things when I hear "bow saw".

 

[SteveMP]

That's useful, thanks. I might have to add that to the birthday wish list!


I don't think I ever would have thought to look that name up: I always think of these things when I hear "bow saw".

That is also a bow saw. Thats why i said its confusing. By the way, if you have never seen this, this is what a master can do with a frame/bow saw:

 

[AndyP]

Don’t force it just get a bigger hammer

 

[AJB Temple]

I've never owned or used a bow saw. Interesting to see them in action.

 

[Pinch]

Very nice. I used to love working with walnut, especially American Black. Your banana for scale reminds me of a particular Facebook group.

Great job!

 

[AndyT]

I do agree that the terminology, as so often is loose and not something to get hung up about.

But I'll add one thing to add to the discussion, which is to think about how to hold these saws. With the sort of small saw that Steve has just made, it's normal to have a long handle at one side and a smaller knob on the other. It's natural to hold the saw with the long handle in your dominant hand and the knob in your other, a bit like you would hold a large file. But it's not always the best way. As ever, we have variables such as the type of wood being sawn, its thickness and how it's orientated. So if your first grip doesn't feel right, try a different one.

Watching the video of Frank Klausz (who is clearly a very experienced craftsman worth watching closely) he starts off with the larger saw holding the frame above the obvious handle, which gives him better control to keep the blade vertical.

When he swaps to the other saw, he uses a two handed grip, with one hand wrapped around the other, enclosing the handle.

I suggest it's worth experimenting with both those grips, on any size of framed saw - the best one is whatever works best for you.

And here are a couple more illustrations of the two handed grip.

This is from Charles Hayward's "Tools for Woodwork" from 1946




And these are from Simon Barley's 2016 "British Saws" - I think it's from an old tool catalogue - where I think it's safe to assume that "Old Clegg" would have been quite well-informed about saw handles:

 

[SteveMP]

I do agree that the terminology, as so often is loose and not something to get hung up about.

But I'll add one thing to add to the discussion, which is to think about how to hold these saws. With the sort of small saw that Steve has just made, it's normal to have a long handle at one side and a smaller knob on the other. It's natural to hold the saw with the long handle in your dominant hand and the knob in your other, a bit like you would hold a large file. But it's not always the best way. As ever, we have variables such as the type of wood being sawn, its thickness and how it's orientated. So if your first grip doesn't feel right, try a different one.

Watching the video of Frank Klausz (who is clearly a very experienced craftsman worth watching closely) he starts off with the larger saw holding the frame above the obvious handle, which gives him better control to keep the blade vertical.

When he swaps to the other saw, he uses a two handed grip, with one hand wrapped around the other, enclosing the handle.

I suggest it's worth experimenting with both those grips, on any size of framed saw - the best one is whatever works best for you.

And here are a couple more illustrations of the two handed grip.

This is from Charles Hayward's "Tools for Woodwork" from 1946

View attachment 57209


And these are from Simon Barley's 2016 "British Saws" - I think it's from an old tool catalogue - where I think it's safe to assume that "Old Clegg" would have been quite well-informed about saw handles:

View attachment 57210

View attachment 57211

Good stuff! Thank you for sharing. Thats a beautiful saw that Old Clegg (not to be confused with Old Gregg) has there. The one i made definitely has a larger handle and a knob. I guess it also helps to tell which way the blade is since its hard to see those small teeth. Makes sense on the grip. Like I mentioned, i thought the little indents on the side were just decorative as I made them from the plans, but once i held them i realized it actually contours your finger really nicely.

By the way, for anyone that watches the Frank Klausz and does a double take at what his saw blade does when he cuts out the waste. Its a trick where you put a twist in the end of the blade. Bow/frame/coping saws you can have the handles and pins in separate planes, so one can be horizontal and the other vertical, use some pliers to twist the leading section to start the cut. This video explains it better than i can with words:

 

[Dr.Al]

That's a really neat trick, thanks for sharing the video.